Dna evidence, when properly collected and analyzed, and when relevant to an alleged crime, can have extraordinary value in the adjudication of a criminal case. There is a lesser chance of contamination with fewer handlers and a shorter chain of custody. Maintaining a chain of custody is essential for the forensic scientist that is. Chain of custody is defined as the documentation of the history of samples through all. Use of dna information in the legal system dna technology in. It is a must to assure the court of law that the evidence is authentic, i. Dna profiling is a forensic technique in criminal investigations, comparing criminal suspects profiles to dna evidence so as to assess the likelihood of their involvement in the crime. After days of putting the dna evidence under a shadow, the jury couldnt convict beyond a reasonable doubt and simpson was acquitted. Through either evidence or admissions by the defence, the prosecution will have to show that the evidence has been kept safe, without tampering, prior. This notebook is designed to help defense attorneys understand. Maintaining the chain of custody is vital for any type of evidence.
The collection and preservation of dna evidence must be done by the book. The concatenation of detention records the followers. Clients should have complete confidence that their samples have been placed into properly labeled envelopes or containers, sealed, and. Evidence found at the scene of a crime must eventually be presented and questioned in the courtroom. What every investigator and evidence technician should know about dna evidence. Dna evidence places malone at the bloodsoaked murder scene of his estranged. Purchase forensic evidence field guide 1st edition. The chain of custody is the most critical process of evidence documentation. Calling the evidence chain of custody evidence, ironically offers a clue to why this might not be so. Chain of custody typically refers to the foundation the prosecution needs to establish for certain types of exhibits to be admitted into evidence. If a defendant alleges an image has been altered, or could have been altered, the burden of proof falls upon the state to prove otherwise.
An accurate chain of custody identifies and tracks the evidence from the time it was collectedincluding the method by which it was obtainedthrough final. The importance of chain of custody for legal proceedings. A true story of law enforcement and one womans bravery. A chain of evidence in a crime like burglary, it requires the prosecutor to come up with a chain of custody. For example, in a paternity court case, a lab that follows the chain of custody collects and tests the dna. Lessons learned from evidence gathering mistakes in simpson case.
Zinnikas, fbinyojttf chain of custody is the ability to give an accurate accounting in a court of law as to the manner in which evidence was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc. Chain of custody and dna laboratory freebooksummary. The only dna laboratory directed by a medical doctor, with years of experience testifying in u. Chain of custody is important for computer evidence because it helps to make sure that the investigation is under control. A clear chain of command eliminates the possibility of a particular sample being altered or swapped, therefore providing all involved parties with the assurance that the results are accurate. The chain of custody documentation provides information regarding the collection, transportation, storage, and general handling of the electronic evidence. In chain of custody, harold levy describes the plight of michael malone, a cardiologist turned highpowered lawyer. For the evidence to be of use in a trial, it must make the journey from crime scene to court in a validated and secure manner so that all involved can be assured that it has not been contaminated and that the evidence is relevant to the crime investigation. There are several principles that guide dna evidence collection by the crime scene examiner. Law essays on the chain of custody assignment carescorp. A true story of law enforcement and one womans bravery detroit, michael on.
The documentation of evidence is key for maintaining a chain of custody. Forensic evidence field guide 1st edition elsevier. For additional e books and books, please search the book catalog. Use of dna information in the legal system dna technology. Dna paternity testing chain of custody genex diagnostics. Chain of custody definition, examples, cases, processes. These samples have to be controlled throughout the entire process to ensure that they cannot be tampered with or mixed up with other samples. Science and the law as dna evidence becomes an increasingly important and common aspect of law enforcement investigations, courtroom evidence, and postconviction litigation. When a defendants attorney argues the police failed to maintain proper control over collected evidence, the allegation is that a violation of the chain of custody has occurred. The chain of custody is essential in legal and judicial settings. In any situation involving child custody laws, you need dna test results that will hold up in court. Chain of custody coc, in legal contexts, is the chronological documentation or paper trail that records the sequence of custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical or electronic evidence. If the evidence or sample followed the chain of custody, it hasnt been tampered with in any way. Texas police thought they had a cold case solved, then they.
A key component to most investigations is the successful recognition, documentation, collection, and preservation of evidence from a crime scene. The term chain of custody refers to the process of maintaining and documenting the handling of evidence. Crime scene evidence collection and chain of custody. Tritechforensics provides evidence collection and crime scene investigation products to crime laboratories and crime scene investigators throughout the world. This constitutes the initiation or beginning of the chain of custody that must be documented up until the time the evidence is introduced. The evaluation of forensic dna evidence reports on developments in population genetics and statistics since the original volume was published. It is important to not only document what is being obtained, but who is doing the collection, when it was collected, and other details that validate the evidence. Chain of custody can be one of the most difficult issues faced by the forensic professional trying to introduce a digital image as evidence in a criminal case. Dna evidence can provide powerful evidence in support of a. You need to pay more and get a legal paternity test. Im glad i didnt this time, for this is a terrific mystery and my judgment has almost nothing to do with the fact that levy went to yale. Continuity evidence in criminal cases a somewhat defence.
Criminal law chain of custody the state has provided sufficient evidence to show that there is a reasonable probability that no tampering occurred. Chain of custody legal dna test chain of custody refers to the chain of procedures carried out to ensure the identity of the dna samples being tested. Chain of custody record national institute of justice. West publishing, volume 32, chapter 21, section 1034,honorable leonard arnold, j. Dna evidence places malone at the bloodsoaked murder scene of his estranged wife, a deputy da who was suing him for custody of their only child. This chapter provides an overview of how dna evidence might be used in the investigation and prosecution of crimes and in civil litigation. If by chance that there was a contamination, it can be traced to a specific point in the chain of custody. Every person who handles evidence must be accounted for and recorded as a link in an unbroken chain of custody, from crime scene to courtroom. Malone is accused of murder and the evidence against him is convincing. For example, much of the controversy surrounding the o.
Improving chain of custody in forensic investigation of. Many different forms of evidence will be encountered. The procedure for establishing chain of custody starts with the crime scene. Documentation is critical to maintaining the integrity of the chain of custody. Hines contends, however, that there is a break in the chain of custody because the kit was. Although it is a lengthy process, it is required for evidence to be. Mistakes that officers make during investigations officers err when they either fail to make the record at the earliest opportunity or do make a record days or weeks later and must rely on faulty recollection. Chain of custody chain of evidence statpearls ncbi bookshelf. Temporary protective custody notice word best if printed in triplicate cruelty case intake form. In r v mcnair unreported, supreme court of victoria court of appeal, 8 may 1997, the victorian court of appeal doubted a direction, given in a dna case, that continuity in the circumstances of that case, had to be proved beyond. Chain of custody chain of evidence statpearls ncbi. Chain of custody coc is defined as the ability to give an accurate accounting in a tribunal of jurisprudence as to the mode in which the grounds was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc. It is also used in parentage testing, 2 to establish immigration eligibility, 3 and in genealogical and medical research.
Chain of custody in a criminal case legal guides avvo. How to challenge chain of custody issues in las vegas. Maintaining the chain of custody evidence handling in. Front matter the evaluation of forensic dna evidence. The chain of custody of this particular dna evidence is not the only troubling. Lessons learned from evidence gathering mistakes in. Chainofcustody coc is defined as the ability to give an accurate accounting in a tribunal of jurisprudence as to the mode in which the grounds was acquired, maintained, transported, examined, etc. If you are offcampus, use your library number to access the online resources. The book covers a wide range of evidence collection and management. That way the court can be certain who provided the dna samples for testing. First, hines admits there is no affirmative evidence of tampering. This easytouse deskbook helps law enforcement, prosecutors, defense attorneys, legal. Chain of custody research and development forensics investigations need to know learning teaching study studying a leader in the forensics market, tritech forensics, inc.
To make the evidence admissible, the chain of custody and handling of the. The importance of collection, custody and preservation of forensic evidence 1560 words 7 pages the collection, custody and preservation of forensic evidence is a vital aspect of evidence integrity, without proper adherence to these procedures, crucial evidence that could potentially have great impact on a court case could be rendered useless. How to document your chain of custody and why its important. A typical chain of custody form will describe the evidence and detail the location and conditions under which the evidence was collected. But malone fears he is more than the prime suspect. The chain of custody of evidence is a record of individuals who have had physical possession of the evidence. The chain of custody form ccf or coc is used to record all changes in the seizure, custody, control, transfer, analysis, and disposition of physical and electronic evidence. The chain of custody must survive at least four transfers. Chain of custody describes the documentation of a piece of evidence through its life cycle. The dna typing discussed in this chapter is mainly standard singlelocus rflp typing on southern blots without apparent band shifting. Of particular importance in criminal cases, the concept is also applied in civil litigationand sometimes more broadly in drug testing of athletes, and in supply chain management, e. The importance of collection, custody and preservation of. Mar 12, 2017 the judge found that prosecutors could not account for the chain of custody of dna evidence collected in 1970, so they couldnt use it against 72yearold willie johnson, a former fort bliss.
Dna samples can be obtained from the tiniest evidence. The las vegas chain of custody refers to the foundation that the prosecution needs in order to establish that certain types of evidence can be admitted at trial. This chapter provides an overview of how dna evidence might be used in the. This blog is the second in a series and shares a few tidbits on evidence collection and chain of custody the first blog covered crime scene lighting. In other words it is the chronological certification demoing the ictus, detention. Chain of custody describes a process as testified to by an. Alison hutchens, forensic supervisor with the durham police department taught the crime scene processing evidence packaging class which was very interesting and packed full of information. This chapter describes the components of a chain of custody and the procedures for the use. Evidence needs to follow a chain of custody, or the processes for documenting, collecting, and protecting evidence. Criminal justice system professionals will appreciate forensic dna evidence.
This means you cannot use any form of home dna test. The sample collector, verifies all tested parties identification, takes photos and has each tested party attest to their identity. The dna test results of biological material on a napkin kept by the victim were determined to be consistent with petitioners. Chain of custody is highly important in any dna testing process, to ensure that results are 100 percent reliable and have not been tampered with in any way. Without a continuous record showing that evidence has been kept safe and secure from the crime scene to the lab and ultimately the courtroom, evidence may be rendered inadmissible in court. A large final section on dna evidence in the simpson case overlaps with lees previous book, cracking cases. By maintaining a chain of custody this will help keep record of all documentation that identifies all changes in the control, handling, possession, ownership, or custody of any piece of evidence.
This easytouse deskbook helps law enforcement, prosecutors, defense attorneys, legal educators, and the judiciary keep pace and. Simpson murder trial in the 1990s was due to improper chain of custody and evidence handling. Warrant check list appendix d of manual investigation check list appendix e of manual back to index. By following the chain of custody, you can see where an item of evidence has been from the moment it was collected to the time it is offered as evidence in a criminal trial. These key pieces of evidence are relevant to the facts of the case and can determine whether a defendant is found guilty or not. How forensics experts protect the chain of custody dummies. Maintaining the chain of custody involves preserving the integrity of evidence by documenting its possession from the moment of collection until the moment it is introduced in court. A proper chain of custody requires three types of testimony. Providing an accurate and complete chain of custody record ensures that the evidence that arrives in court is what was collected at the crime scene. In a legal test all participants get tested in person at a lab. Chain of custody is a graphic, satisfying read that delves into a controversial subject in a sympathetic and humane way. In order for the dna test outcomes to be recognized for usage in us courtrooms, not only are test results required to exceed cpi 100 for inclusions and 0 or exclusions genex results are at least x more accurate than what is required by cour, but the strict chain of custody maintained throughout sample collections and analysis at the laboratory is also of consideration. May 15, 2012 the chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Establishing a solid chain of evidence is one of those basic, essential standards.
The chain of custody is the roadmap for the evidence gathered in a criminal case. Chain of custody coc, in legal contexts, is the chronological documentation or paper trail that. Forensic analyst jack analyses the iron rod at the laboratory and collects. There are general principles that apply to the proper collection, preservation, and handling of all evidence. If the man is excluded by the test, she can block his attempt to obtain legal child custody or even temporary child custody. It involves keeping a detailed log showing who collected, handled, transferred, or analyzed evidence during an investigation. Mar 30, 2020 for additional e books and books, please search the book catalog.
A typical chain of custody form will describe the evidence and detail the location and conditions under which the evidence. Chain of custody digital forensics and incident response. He is the prime targetin a farreaching conspiracy of merciless revenge and police coverup. How improper dna evidence collection can compromise your case. May 15, 20 it is called chain of custody because during the sample collection process and testing process, the dna samples follow a strict and documented chain of custody. Practice, criminal procedure by honorable leonard arnoldretired, j. You are defense counsel in a case with dna evidence or where the absence of dna evidence may raise factual or legal issues. The chain of custody is the means of verifying the authenticity and legal integrity of trace or sample evidence by establishing where the evidence has been and who handled it prior to the trial. This book is distributed under the terms of the creative commons. Although this is a common plot in legal thrillers, levy does a good job of raising this novel a few notches above the ordinary. Exhibits are tangible objects that are relevant to the facts of a casefor example.
Mar 01, 2002 in other words, if you break the chain, you dont have any authoritative way of linking the evidence to the crime. Although this is a common plot in legal thrillers, levy does a good job of raising this novel a. The committee comments on statements in the original book that proved controversial or that have been misapplied in the courts. The following is an excerpt drawn from this assignment sample answer. Of particular importance in criminal cases, the concept is also applied in civil litigationand sometimes more broadly in drug. Botha v s pe2772015, r33216 2017 zaecghc 29 7 march. The ultimate goal of evidence collection is to prevent loss, damage and contamination while maintaining a proper chain of custody. But improper dna evidence collection could destroy your case.
This life cycle begins when an individual first takes custody of the piece of evidence to when the incident is finally disposed of and the evidence can either be returned or destroyed. Glossary chain of custody for legal dna testing easydna. The setting is modern india and the author homes in on the lucrative business of child trafficking, centred here on bangalore but with tentacles extending throughout the subcontinent. A chain of custody is necessary if there is any possibility that litigants will use analytical data or conclusions based upon that data in litigation.
757 1597 1587 774 217 936 1599 319 1240 88 581 929 330 1325 814 1578 1609 40 47 66 188 1602 913 460 1143 652 1228 1360 1039 1500 682 139 443 567 1010 556 7 46 781 226 582 803 1343 1393 968